[Scene: A countryside walk in the Lake District. The two friends stop near a sacred well surrounded by trees with colourful ribbons and cloths tied to the branches.]
Emma: (smiling) Look at this, Liam! Isn’t it beautiful? All those ribbons fluttering in the wind — each one carrying someone’s wish. I’m definitely tying one today.
Liam: (grinning) You mean you’re adding to the world’s most colourful litter collection?
Emma: (gasps) Litter? How dare you! These aren’t bits of rubbish — they’re blessings. People have been tying cloths here for centuries to ask for good fortune. It’s a sacred tradition.
Liam: (teasing) Sacred or not, Emma, it’s still polyester flapping on a tree. I’m sure Mother Nature didn’t ask for a scarf collection.
Emma: You’re so cynical. My nan swore by this! She tied a piece of her handkerchief at a well like this one before my uncle’s exams — and he passed with flying colours!
Liam: Or maybe your uncle passed because he studied, Emma. The cloth didn’t whisper the answers into his ear during the test.
Emma: (rolling eyes) You can’t explain everything with logic, you know. Sometimes, you just have to believe. These places have special energy — people come here to connect with something bigger than themselves.
Liam: I agree with that part — the emotional connection. But the rest is pure coincidence dressed up as magic. People remember the cloth when things go right, and forget about it when nothing happens.
Emma: (pointing at a branch) See that blue ribbon? The woman who tied it said her husband found a new job the next week. Coincidence?
Liam: (nodding) Statistically, yes. Out of all the people who tie ribbons, someone is bound to have good news soon after. That’s just probability — not proof.
Emma: You and your “probability.” Sometimes I think you’d rather talk to a calculator than a person.
Liam: (laughs) Depends on the person. Calculators don’t argue about magical trees.
Emma: (smiling) You’ll laugh now, but don’t come running to me when your car breaks down and you need some good luck. I’ll be too busy tying my next ribbon.
Liam: (pretending to take notes) Ah yes — next time I have engine trouble, I’ll find the nearest oak and tie my shoelace to it. That’ll surely fix the carburettor.
Emma: (giggles) You’re impossible. Still, I’d rather believe in something hopeful than just think life is random chaos.
Liam: Fair point. I think traditions like this are lovely — as long as people don’t mistake hope for evidence. If it gives comfort, fine. Just don’t claim physics agrees with it.
Emma: Deal. I’ll keep believing in good fortune — and you can keep believing in your science.
Liam: (smirking) Perfect. You tie your ribbon, and I’ll recycle the packaging. Balance restored to the universe.
Emma: (tying a small piece of cloth carefully) There. My wish is made.
Liam: (grinning) I hope it’s for me to finally win an argument with you.
Emma: (winks) Sorry, Liam. Some things are even beyond the power of sacred wells.
[They both laugh as the wind rustles through the ribbons — the colours dancing like hope itself, caught somewhere between faith and reason.]
Science Vs Superstition 
Tell Us What You Think