Setting: A sunny afternoon at a café in Seville. Two friends, Lucía (the superstitious one) and Marcos (the rational thinker), are sipping sangria at a small outdoor table. Lucía has just accidentally spilled a bit of wine on the table.
Lucía: (gasps with delight) ¡Ay, qué suerte! I spilled wine! You know what that means, right?
Marcos: (raising an eyebrow) It means you’re terrible with coordination and we need more napkins?
Lucía: (laughing, dabbing the spill with a napkin, then dabbing her forehead with it) No, no! It’s a good omen! Spilling wine means happiness is coming. And if you touch your forehead with it, it attracts joy into your life. Everyone in my family does this. Even abuela swears it worked for her.
Marcos: Lucía, your abuela also believes putting garlic under the bed keeps away bad dreams.
Lucía: Exactly, and she never had nightmares. Coincidence? I think not.
Marcos: Or maybe it’s just that garlic under your pillow is really uncomfortable and distracting—enough to keep your mind off nightmares.
Lucía: You’re no fun, Marcos. Just imagine, all this joy I’m attracting and you’re sitting there like Mr. Science with your skepticism glasses on.
Marcos: Okay, okay. I’ll play along. But let’s look at it this way—if spilling wine guaranteed happiness, every clumsy waiter in Spain would be a millionaire in therapy bills and the happiest person on Earth.
Lucía: That’s because intent matters! It has to be accidental but heartfelt. Like the universe saying, “Here, have a moment of chaos so you can receive something beautiful.”
Marcos: Poetic. But if that’s the case, I’ve had a lot of “universal gifts” every time I’ve knocked over a glass. I must be due for a yacht and a Nobel Prize by now.
Lucía: (giggling) Maybe the universe knows you don’t believe, so it holds back. You need faith, Marcos. Belief opens the door.
Marcos: Or belief makes you think the door opened, even if you walked into a wall. It’s classic confirmation bias—you remember the times something good followed a wine spill, but not the hundreds of spills that led to nothing but stains and awkward apologies.
Lucía: Not true! I spilled wine before my job interview last year, touched my forehead like always—and guess what? I got the job the next day.
Marcos: And how many interviews did you not get after a spill?
Lucía: Well… I try not to dwell on those. Negativity blocks the flow, you know?
Marcos: Ah yes, the ever-convenient mystical filter. Only the good stuff counts.
Lucía: Don’t mock it, Marcos. People need rituals. It gives them comfort, a sense of control. Life’s messy—we don’t always have scientific answers for everything. Sometimes a little superstition adds color.
Marcos: I get that. I’m not saying rituals are bad. I think they have value—psychological value. If touching your forehead with wine makes you feel confident before a job interview, that boost in confidence might be what actually helps you perform better.
Lucía: So you do believe it works?
Marcos: I believe you work. The ritual might help you focus, or ease your nerves. But it’s not the wine spill. It’s your brain tricking itself into being more awesome. Which is kind of amazing in its own right.
Lucía: Hmm. So you’re saying it’s all in my head?
Marcos: Exactly. But not in a dismissive way. The mind is powerful. Placebos are real. Confidence is real. But spilled wine isn’t magic. It’s psychology wearing a flamenco dress.
Lucía: (smirks) That’s the most Andalusian metaphor I’ve ever heard. I’ll take it. But I’m still touching my forehead every time. Just in case.
Marcos: Fair enough. Just don’t spill it on my laptop next time. Or the universe will owe me a new one.
Lucía: Deal. But if I do, I’ll dab your forehead too—for extra happiness.
Marcos: (laughs) Only if you buy me a new shirt afterward.
[Scene fades with both laughing as the waiter approaches with more napkins and a knowing smile.]
Science Vs Superstition 
Tell Us What You Think