Setting:
A cozy café in Berlin on a chilly autumn afternoon. Two friends, Jonas (the rational thinker) and Felix (the superstitious one), sit sipping their cappuccinos, watching people and the occasional dog pass by.
Felix:
(suddenly stiffens, eyes wide)
Did you see that?
Jonas:
(blinks)
What? The dachshund in the sweater?
Felix:
No! That black cat! It just crossed from right to left.
We’re doomed, Jonas. Something bad is definitely going to happen today.
Jonas:
(laughs)
Felix, come on. It’s just a cat. It’s probably on its way to scare a pigeon or take a nap under a car.
Felix:
You don’t understand. My Oma always said that if a black cat crosses from right to left, it’s a sign of misfortune. If it’s left to right, good luck is coming. And she was always right.
Jonas:
Your Oma also believed garlic keeps away vampires. Doesn’t mean Bram Stoker was writing science textbooks.
Felix:
Okay, but—listen to this. Last year, I was heading to a job interview. A black cat ran across my path—right to left. I tripped on the tram stairs and tore my trousers. Didn’t get the job. Coincidence?
Jonas:
Maybe. Or maybe you tripped because your shoelaces were undone. I remember you saying you were rushing and didn’t eat breakfast. That sounds more like poor planning than feline voodoo.
Felix:
And the week after? Cat crossed left to right. I found a €50 note outside the Rewe and got free currywurst. You can’t tell me that’s not proof.
Jonas:
Felix, statistically, black cats cross roads all the time. But your brain only logs the ones that match the outcome. It’s confirmation bias. Like thinking it rains every time you forget your umbrella—but ignoring all the times it didn’t.
Felix:
(grinning)
I knew you’d bring up confirmation bias. You always do. You’re like a walking TED Talk.
Jonas:
I’ll take that as a compliment. But seriously—black cats got their bad rap in medieval Europe because people associated them with witches. The direction thing? Probably just tacked on later to make it sound more mystical.
Felix:
Still… sometimes it feels real. Like the universe is trying to send a sign.
Jonas:
Sure, I get that. Humans are pattern-hungry. It’s how we survived—recognizing danger, predicting outcomes. But we also invented horoscopes, so… you know, we’re not always spot-on.
Felix:
So you’re saying I should just ignore my instincts?
Jonas:
Not ignore. Just… question them. If a cat can supposedly change your destiny just by choosing a sidewalk, doesn’t that seem like giving animals too much power? What if it crosses diagonally? What then—moderate luck?
Felix:
(laughs)
Ha! Maybe that means I find €5 and lose my favorite sock on the same day.
Jonas:
Exactly. You get warm toes and a lottery ticket, and the universe is like, “Let’s call it even.”
Felix:
Alright, alright. Maybe I won’t panic next time. But I am carrying an extra pair of trousers on interview days. Just in case.
Jonas:
That’s not superstition—that’s just smart planning.
Felix:
You win this round, Herr Wissenschaft. But I still won’t walk under ladders.
Jonas:
Deal. But if you start throwing salt over your shoulder again, I’m calling your therapist.
[They clink coffee cups and laugh, as another black cat casually walks by—completely ignored this time.]
Science Vs Superstition 
Tell Us What You Think