Setting: A cozy German kitchen in Hamburg. Two friends, Lukas (the rational thinker) and Felix (the superstitious one), are sitting at the table sipping coffee. A tiny porcelain pig and a horseshoe hang above the door, and a red mushroom ornament sits on the windowsill.
Felix: (gesturing to the windowsill) See? I told you that little fly agaric mushroom would bring us luck! I found a 10-euro note on the street this morning.
Lukas: (chuckles) Felix, it’s more likely someone dropped that after buying Brötchen. You just happened to walk by. Mushroom or no mushroom.
Felix: Come on, Lukas. That’s the third time this month I’ve had good luck after spotting one of my Glückssymbole. Last week it was a ladybug on my jacket and I passed my TÜV inspection — no issues!
Lukas: You do realize correlation isn’t causation, right? Maybe your car passed because it was… I don’t know… mechanically sound?
Felix: Pfft, and what about the time I wore my clover-print socks during the job interview and got the job?
Lukas: Maybe because you’re qualified? Maybe because you didn’t mention those socks?
Felix: Okay, fair, I didn’t. But still—don’t you ever feel like there’s more to the world than logic can explain?
Lukas: Sure. The universe is full of mysteries. But using symbols like pigs and horseshoes to explain luck? That’s tradition, not truth.
Felix: But tradition has meaning. Horseshoes above doors go back to medieval times. People believed iron warded off evil spirits.
Lukas: People also believed bathing was unhealthy in the 14th century. Doesn’t mean we should go back to that.
Felix: Ew, okay, point taken. But ladybugs! Everyone agrees they’re good luck. Even scientists like them — they eat pests!
Lukas: That’s true. They’re beneficial insects, sure. But that doesn’t mean they influence your exam results or your dating life.
Felix: You’re just saying that because your last date didn’t go well.
Lukas: She brought a rabbit’s foot. I spent the evening trying not to think about dead bunnies.
Felix: Maybe it would’ve gone better if you carried a lucky pig figurine. Want to borrow mine?
Lukas: I appreciate the offer, but I prefer my luck the old-fashioned way—through preparation, skill, and coffee.
Felix: Well, I believe in stacking the odds and having mushroom charms. Belt and suspenders, my friend.
Lukas: Felix, if believing in Glücksschweinchen helps you face the world with confidence, fine. Just don’t expect them to fix your leaky sink.
Felix: I’d never! That’s what plumbers are for. Although… the plumber did have a four-leaf clover tattoo…
Lukas: I give up. Want more coffee?
Felix: Only if it comes with a side of statistically insignificant miracles.
Lukas: Coming right up.
(They laugh and toast their mugs, neither convinced but both content to disagree—at least until the next lucky charm shows up.)
Science Vs Superstition 
Tell Us What You Think