[Scene: A cozy café in Lyon, France. Two friends, Camille and Thomas, are sipping coffee at a small table by the window. A little rabbit’s foot keychain dangles from Camille’s handbag.]
Camille: (excitedly waving the rabbit’s foot) Thomas, you won’t believe it! I won €50 at the casino last night — and guess what I had in my pocket?
Thomas: (smirking) Hmm… let me guess. A lucky rabbit’s foot?
Camille: Exactly! See? It works. I told you, Thomas — this little charm has been with me through three first dates, a job interview, and now blackjack glory. It’s magical.
Thomas: (chuckling) Camille, you realize that statistically, someone wins something at the casino every night — rabbit’s foot or not. It’s called chance, not magic.
Camille: Oh, come on! Don’t ruin my fun with your statistics. Besides, it’s not just the casino. Remember last month when I met Julien at that party? I had the rabbit’s foot with me then, too. Now we’re going on date number four.
Thomas: And maybe — just maybe — Julien likes you, not your keychain?
Camille: Well… sure, but why risk it? I mean, why tempt fate when the rabbit’s foot is clearly on my side?
Thomas: (raising an eyebrow) Camille, you know the rabbit didn’t exactly get lucky, right? That foot is only “lucky” because some old folk belief said it was. There’s no scientific evidence that a rabbit’s foot affects outcomes. It’s all about confirmation bias — you remember the wins, but you forget the times it didn’t help.
Camille: Pff, confirmation bias! You sound like a psychology textbook. Besides, science doesn’t explain everything. What about intuition, vibes, little nudges from the universe?
Thomas: Okay, okay — but hear me out. Imagine this: you go to the casino without the rabbit’s foot. You win €50 again. Would you admit it’s just your skill or luck?
Camille: Hmm… I’d probably rush home and apologize to the rabbit foot for leaving it behind.
Thomas: (laughing) See? That’s the problem. You’re giving credit to the charm no matter what. That’s like me saying my morning croissant determines how good my day is.
Camille: Maybe it does! A bad croissant can ruin anyone’s mood.
Thomas: Fair point. But seriously, wouldn’t it feel empowering to know you are responsible for your successes, not some furry charm?
Camille: I don’t see it as giving up power. To me, it’s like… carrying a little reminder of hope, of possibility. Besides, it makes me smile. Don’t scientists say positive thinking improves outcomes?
Thomas: Touché. Positive thinking does help — but that’s about you, not the charm. You could carry a pebble, a button, or even a photo of your cat, and the effect might be the same.
Camille: But a pebble doesn’t have a legend! Where’s the romance in that?
Thomas: (grinning) So it’s really about the story, then? The magic we want to believe in?
Camille: Exactly! Life’s already so logical and measured. Isn’t it nice to have a little whimsy, a sprinkle of magic?
Thomas: Fair enough. As long as you don’t start sacrificing carrots to your keychain, I can live with it.
Camille: (laughing) Deal. But next time you need a little luck — say, for that research grant application — don’t come crying to me when you don’t have a rabbit’s foot.
Thomas: Hmm… maybe I’ll just borrow yours. But only for… scientific purposes, of course.
Camille: (grinning) Of course.
[They clink their coffee cups together, laughing as the rain begins to fall softly outside.]
Science Vs Superstition 
Tell Us What You Think